Should Someone Else Pick Your Dating Profile Photo?

You’ve narrowed it down to two photos. In one, the lighting is doing a heroic amount of work. In the other, you look like you laughed before anyone said “smile.” You choose the first. Someone seeing your face for the first time might choose the second.
If you’re stuck choosing a dating profile photo, get a second opinion before you take another fifty. A study found that photos chosen by someone who didn’t know the person pictured could make more favorable first impressions than photos people chose for themselves. The wrinkle is that the advantage wasn’t a clear boost in how attractive the photos looked. So the most useful question for your second pair of eyes may be something other than “Which one makes me look hottest?”
The same person, twelve possible introductions
David White, Clare Sutherland, and Amy Burton started with twelve photos each from 102 students. The images came from the students’ Facebook galleries, so a single set could contain different expressions, angles, and lighting. What stayed the same was the person in the pictures. That let the researchers ask how much the choice of photograph, rather than the choice of face, could change an impression.
Participants considered pictures of themselves and of someone they didn’t know. They made selections for three imagined settings: Facebook, a dating site, and a professional network. There was no reason to expect one photo to win everywhere. A picture that looks right beside a résumé could look as if you’d like your date to email you an agenda.
Then came the part that mattered: unfamiliar viewers rated the photos. In one experiment, the researchers looked at how well the participants’ preferences matched those viewers’ ratings across sets of pictures. The advantage for someone else’s choices was clearest in the professional setting. That analysis didn’t find a reliable advantage in the dating setting.
The researchers followed up with a more direct comparison. A new group of viewers rated photographs that had been picked as most or least likely to be used in each setting. This time, the gap between the ratings of the top and bottom picks was larger when another person did the choosing, including for the dating setting. Across settings, the advantage was clearer for impressions of trustworthiness and competence. There was no reliable advantage for attractiveness ratings.
What a stranger can see that you might miss
Imagine a photo from a wedding. You remember feeling good that night. You know why the jacket looks familiar, whose arm is at the edge of the frame, and how hard a friend worked to get the one frame in which nobody was blinking. A person looking at the photo for the first time knows exactly none of that. They get whatever the expression, pose, and surroundings communicate on their own.
The study didn’t establish that memories are what make people choose differently. But the example illustrates why another person’s view can be useful even when they disagree with yours: they’re looking at the photo with less of the story attached. That’s closer to the job the photo will have to do on a profile.
That doesn’t make your own taste useless. In the study, people adjusted their picks to the setting, and their own choices tended to favor the impressions they themselves saw in the photos. The outside opinion helps with a different question: what comes through to someone else?
And those impressions are just impressions. A face rated as more trustworthy on a screen doesn’t tell you whether its owner returns borrowed books. The researchers measured judgments about pictures, not character, messages, matches, or whether anyone actually wanted a second date. The participants who did the choosing were also strangers to the people in the photos. The study didn’t compare a stranger’s pick with your closest friend’s.
Ask what the photo says
Try putting three or four recent photos side by side. Include ones you’d genuinely be comfortable using, not one serious contender and three photos you’d describe in court as sabotage. Ask someone to look at them without hearing which one you like or why:
“If you didn’t know me, which would you put first? What would you assume about me from it?”
The second question is the useful one. An answer like “You look easy to talk to in this one” or “I can’t tell which person is you” gives you something specific to work with. “This one is better” leaves you where you started, except now there are two votes to argue with. A friend is a convenient person to ask, even if they can only approximate the unfamiliar viewer used in the research.
Give their pick a fair look, then choose the picture you’d be happy to show up as. If they favor a photo that doesn’t feel like you, you can use their reason without using their choice. Maybe they liked how easy it was to see your face, or how relaxed your expression looked. Look for that quality in a photo you’d actually want on the profile. This little exercise is an editorial suggestion, not a method the researchers tested.
It’s also fine if the photo you like best stays your favorite. You may love it because it takes you back to a night worth remembering. A dating profile is asking that picture to do another job: introduce you to someone who hasn’t met you yet. Their fresh look can help you choose the introduction. You still get to decide how you want to say hello.
Research: White, D., Sutherland, C. A. M. S., & Burton, A. L. (2017). Choosing face: The curse of self in profile image selection. Cognitive Research: Principles and Implications, 2, 23.
Comments
Post a Comment